InputText: Fixed a tricky edge case, ensuring value is always written back on the frame where IsItemDeactivated() returns true (#4714)

Altered ItemAdd() clipping rule to keep previous-frame ActiveId unclipped to support that late commit.

Also, MarkItemEdited() may in theory need to do:
if (g.ActiveIdPreviousFrame == id)
        g.ActiveIdPreviousFrameHasBeenEditedBefore = true;
But this should already be set so not adding now.

docs/CHANGELOG.txt

@@ -39,6 +39,11 @@ Breaking Changes:
 
 Other changes:
 
+- InputText: Fixed a tricky edge case, ensuring value is always written back on the
+  frame where IsItemDeactivated() returns true, in order to allow usage without user
+  retaining underlying data. While we don't really want to encourage user not retaining
+  underlying data, in the absence of a "late commit" behavior/flag we understand it may
+  be desirable to take advantage of this trick. (#4714)
 - Backends: OpenGL3: Fixed GL loader crash when GL_VERSION returns NULL. (#6154, #4445, #3530)
 - Backends: GLFW: Fixed key modifiers handling on secondary viewports. (#6248, #6034) [@aiekick]
 - Examples: Windows: Added 'misc/debuggers/imgui.natstepfilter' file to all Visual Studio projects,

imgui.cpp

@@ -3587,6 +3587,7 @@ void ImGui::Shutdown()
     g.ClipboardHandlerData.clear();
     g.MenusIdSubmittedThisFrame.clear();
     g.InputTextState.ClearFreeMemory();
+    g.InputTextDeactivatedState.ClearFreeMemory();
 
     g.SettingsWindows.clear();
     g.SettingsHandlers.clear();
@@ -3759,13 +3760,23 @@ void ImGui::SetActiveID(ImGuiID id, ImGuiWindow* window)
 {
     ImGuiContext& g = *GImGui;
 
-    // While most behaved code would make an effort to not steal active id during window move/drag operations,
+    // Clear previous active id
-    // we at least need to be resilient to it. Cancelling the move is rather aggressive and users of 'master' branch
+    if (g.ActiveId != 0)
-    // may prefer the weird ill-defined half working situation ('docking' did assert), so may need to rework that.
-    if (g.MovingWindow != NULL && g.ActiveId == g.MovingWindow->MoveId)
     {
-        IMGUI_DEBUG_LOG_ACTIVEID("SetActiveID() cancel MovingWindow\n");
+        // While most behaved code would make an effort to not steal active id during window move/drag operations,
-        g.MovingWindow = NULL;
+        // we at least need to be resilient to it. Canceling the move is rather aggressive and users of 'master' branch
+        // may prefer the weird ill-defined half working situation ('docking' did assert), so may need to rework that.
+        if (g.MovingWindow != NULL && g.ActiveId == g.MovingWindow->MoveId)
+        {
+            IMGUI_DEBUG_LOG_ACTIVEID("SetActiveID() cancel MovingWindow\n");
+            g.MovingWindow = NULL;
+        }
+
+        // This could be written in a more general way (e.g associate a hook to ActiveId),
+        // but since this is currently quite an exception we'll leave it as is.
+        // One common scenario leading to this is: pressing Key ->NavMoveRequestApplyResult() -> ClearActiveId()
+        if (g.InputTextState.ID == g.ActiveId)
+            InputTextDeactivateHook(g.ActiveId);
     }
 
     // Set active id
@@ -3840,11 +3851,17 @@ void ImGui::MarkItemEdited(ImGuiID id)
     // This marking is solely to be able to provide info for IsItemDeactivatedAfterEdit().
     // ActiveId might have been released by the time we call this (as in the typical press/release button behavior) but still need to fill the data.
     ImGuiContext& g = *GImGui;
-    IM_ASSERT(g.ActiveId == id || g.ActiveId == 0 || g.DragDropActive);
+    if (g.ActiveId == id || g.ActiveId == 0)
-    IM_UNUSED(id); // Avoid unused variable warnings when asserts are compiled out.
+    {
+        g.ActiveIdHasBeenEditedThisFrame = true;
+        g.ActiveIdHasBeenEditedBefore = true;
+    }
+
+    // We accept a MarkItemEdited() on drag and drop targets (see https://github.com/ocornut/imgui/issues/1875#issuecomment-978243343)
+    // We accept 'ActiveIdPreviousFrame == id' for InputText() returning an edit after it has been taken ActiveId away (#4714)
+    IM_ASSERT(g.DragDropActive || g.ActiveId == id || g.ActiveId == 0 || g.ActiveIdPreviousFrame == id);
+
     //IM_ASSERT(g.CurrentWindow->DC.LastItemId == id);
-    g.ActiveIdHasBeenEditedThisFrame = true;
-    g.ActiveIdHasBeenEditedBefore = true;
     g.LastItemData.StatusFlags |= ImGuiItemStatusFlags_Edited;
 }
 
@@ -9293,7 +9310,7 @@ bool ImGui::ItemAdd(const ImRect& bb, ImGuiID id, const ImRect* nav_bb_arg, ImGu
     //    return false;
     const bool is_rect_visible = bb.Overlaps(window->ClipRect);
     if (!is_rect_visible)
-        if (id == 0 || (id != g.ActiveId && id != g.NavId))
+        if (id == 0 || (id != g.ActiveId && id != g.ActiveIdPreviousFrame && id != g.NavId))
             if (!g.LogEnabled)
                 return false;
 

imgui.h

@@ -23,7 +23,7 @@
 // Library Version
 // (Integer encoded as XYYZZ for use in #if preprocessor conditionals, e.g. '#if IMGUI_VERSION_NUM > 12345')
 #define IMGUI_VERSION               "1.89.5 WIP"
-#define IMGUI_VERSION_NUM           18941
+#define IMGUI_VERSION_NUM           18942
 #define IMGUI_HAS_TABLE
 
 /*

imgui_internal.h

@@ -130,6 +130,7 @@ struct ImGuiDataVarInfo;            // Variable information (e.g. to avoid style
 struct ImGuiDataTypeInfo;           // Type information associated to a ImGuiDataType enum
 struct ImGuiGroupData;              // Stacked storage data for BeginGroup()/EndGroup()
 struct ImGuiInputTextState;         // Internal state of the currently focused/edited text input box
+struct ImGuiInputTextDeactivateData;// Short term storage to backup text of a deactivating InputText() while another is stealing active id
 struct ImGuiLastItemData;           // Status storage for last submitted items
 struct ImGuiLocEntry;               // A localization entry.
 struct ImGuiMenuColumns;            // Simple column measurement, currently used for MenuItem() only
@@ -1048,6 +1049,15 @@ struct IMGUI_API ImGuiMenuColumns
     void        CalcNextTotalWidth(bool update_offsets);
 };
 
+// Internal temporary state for deactivating InputText() instances.
+struct IMGUI_API ImGuiInputTextDeactivatedState
+{
+    ImGuiID            ID;              // widget id owning the text state (which just got deactivated)
+    ImVector<char>     TextA;           // text buffer
+
+    ImGuiInputTextDeactivatedState()    { memset(this, 0, sizeof(*this)); }
+    void    ClearFreeMemory()           { ID = 0; TextA.clear(); }
+};
 // Internal state of the currently focused/edited text input box
 // For a given item ID, access with ImGui::GetInputTextState()
 struct IMGUI_API ImGuiInputTextState
@@ -1935,6 +1945,7 @@ struct ImGuiContext
     // Widget state
     ImVec2                  MouseLastValidPos;
     ImGuiInputTextState     InputTextState;
+    ImGuiInputTextDeactivatedState InputTextDeactivatedState;
     ImFont                  InputTextPasswordFont;
     ImGuiID                 TempInputId;                        // Temporary text input when CTRL+clicking on a slider, etc.
     ImGuiColorEditFlags     ColorEditOptions;                   // Store user options for color edit widgets
@@ -3131,6 +3142,7 @@ namespace ImGui
 
     // InputText
     IMGUI_API bool          InputTextEx(const char* label, const char* hint, char* buf, int buf_size, const ImVec2& size_arg, ImGuiInputTextFlags flags, ImGuiInputTextCallback callback = NULL, void* user_data = NULL);
+    IMGUI_API void          InputTextDeactivateHook(ImGuiID id);
     IMGUI_API bool          TempInputText(const ImRect& bb, ImGuiID id, const char* label, char* buf, int buf_size, ImGuiInputTextFlags flags);
     IMGUI_API bool          TempInputScalar(const ImRect& bb, ImGuiID id, const char* label, ImGuiDataType data_type, void* p_data, const char* format, const void* p_clamp_min = NULL, const void* p_clamp_max = NULL);
     inline bool             TempInputIsActive(ImGuiID id)       { ImGuiContext& g = *GImGui; return (g.ActiveId == id && g.TempInputId == id); }

imgui_widgets.cpp

@@ -3999,6 +3999,21 @@ static void InputTextReconcileUndoStateAfterUserCallback(ImGuiInputTextState* st
                 p[i] = ImStb::STB_TEXTEDIT_GETCHAR(state, first_diff + i);
 }
 
+// As InputText() retain textual data and we currently provide a path for user to not retain it (via local variables)
+// we need some form of hook to reapply data back to user buffer on deactivation frame. (#4714)
+// It would be more desirable that we discourage users from taking advantage of the "user not retaining data" trick,
+// but that more likely be attractive when we do have _NoLiveEdit flag available.
+void ImGui::InputTextDeactivateHook(ImGuiID id)
+{
+    ImGuiContext& g = *GImGui;
+    ImGuiInputTextState* state = &g.InputTextState;
+    if (id == 0 || state->ID != id)
+        return;
+    g.InputTextDeactivatedState.ID = state->ID;
+    g.InputTextDeactivatedState.TextA.resize(state->CurLenA + 1);
+    memcpy(g.InputTextDeactivatedState.TextA.Data, state->TextA.Data, state->CurLenA + 1);
+}
+
 // Edit a string of text
 // - buf_size account for the zero-terminator, so a buf_size of 6 can hold "Hello" but not "Hello!".
 //   This is so we can easily call InputText() on static arrays using ARRAYSIZE() and to match
@@ -4113,6 +4128,9 @@ bool ImGui::InputTextEx(const char* label, const char* hint, char* buf, int buf_
         state = &g.InputTextState;
         state->CursorAnimReset();
 
+        // Backup state of deactivating item so they'll have a chance to do a write to output buffer on the same frame they report IsItemDeactivatedAfterEdit (#4714)
+        InputTextDeactivateHook(state->ID);
+
         // Take a copy of the initial buffer value (both in original UTF-8 format and converted to wchar)
         // From the moment we focused we are ignoring the content of 'buf' (unless we are in read-only mode)
         const int buf_len = (int)strlen(buf);
@@ -4525,6 +4543,7 @@ bool ImGui::InputTextEx(const char* label, const char* hint, char* buf, int buf_
                 // Push records into the undo stack so we can CTRL+Z the revert operation itself
                 apply_new_text = state->InitialTextA.Data;
                 apply_new_text_length = state->InitialTextA.Size - 1;
+                value_changed = true;
                 ImVector<ImWchar> w_text;
                 if (apply_new_text_length > 0)
                 {
@@ -4638,10 +4657,24 @@ bool ImGui::InputTextEx(const char* label, const char* hint, char* buf, int buf_
             {
                 apply_new_text = state->TextA.Data;
                 apply_new_text_length = state->CurLenA;
+                value_changed = true;
             }
         }
     }
 
+    // Handle reapplying final data on deactivation (see InputTextDeactivateHook() for details)
+    if (g.InputTextDeactivatedState.ID == id)
+    {
+        if (g.ActiveId != id && IsItemDeactivatedAfterEdit() && !is_readonly)
+        {
+            apply_new_text = g.InputTextDeactivatedState.TextA.Data;
+            apply_new_text_length = g.InputTextDeactivatedState.TextA.Size - 1;
+            value_changed |= (strcmp(g.InputTextDeactivatedState.TextA.Data, buf) != 0);
+            //IMGUI_DEBUG_LOG("InputText(): apply Deactivated data for 0x%08X: \"%.*s\".\n", id, apply_new_text_length, apply_new_text);
+        }
+        g.InputTextDeactivatedState.ID = 0;
+    }
+
     // Copy result to user buffer. This can currently only happen when (g.ActiveId == id)
     if (apply_new_text != NULL)
     {
@@ -4669,7 +4702,6 @@ bool ImGui::InputTextEx(const char* label, const char* hint, char* buf, int buf_
 
         // If the underlying buffer resize was denied or not carried to the next frame, apply_new_text_length+1 may be >= buf_size.
         ImStrncpy(buf, apply_new_text, ImMin(apply_new_text_length + 1, buf_size));
-        value_changed = true;
     }
 
     // Release active ID at the end of the function (so e.g. pressing Return still does a final application of the value)