Fonts: OversampleH/OversampleV value defaults to 0 for automatic selection.

docs/CHANGELOG.txt

@@ -76,11 +76,15 @@ Other changes:
   styles as the current look is not right (but ImGuiCol_TabSelectedOverline stays the same).
 - Debug Tools: Tweaked font preview.
 - ImDrawList: texture baked storage for thick line reduced from ~64x64 to ~32x32. (#3245)
-- ImFontAtlas: made calling ClearFonts() call ClearInputData(), as calling
+- Fonts: IndexLookup[] table hold 16-bit values even in ImWchar32 mode,
-  one without the other is never correct. (#8174, #6556, #6336, #4723)
-- ImFont: IndexLookup[] table hold 16-bit values even in ImWchar32 mode,
   as it accounts for number of glyphs in same font. This is favorable to
   CalcTextSize() calls touching less memory.
+- Fonts: OversampleH/OversampleV defaults to 0 for automatic selection.
+   - OversampleH == 0 --> use 1 or 2 depending on font size and use of PixelSnapH.
+   - OversampleV == 0 --> always use 1.
+  This also
+- ImFontAtlas: made calling ClearFonts() call ClearInputData(), as calling
+  one without the other is never correct. (#8174, #6556, #6336, #4723)
 - Examples: DirectX12: Reduced number of frame in flight from 3 to 2 in
   provided example, to reduce latency.
 - Examples: Vulkan: better handle VK_SUBOPTIMAL_KHR being returned by

docs/FONTS.md

@@ -110,8 +110,6 @@ ImGui::PopFont();
 **For advanced options create a ImFontConfig structure and pass it to the AddFont() function (it will be copied internally):**
 ```cpp
 ImFontConfig config;
-config.OversampleH = 2;
-config.OversampleV = 1;
 config.GlyphExtraSpacing.x = 1.0f;
 ImFont* font = io.Fonts->AddFontFromFileTTF("font.ttf", size_pixels, &config);
 ```

imgui.cpp

@@ -16184,9 +16184,13 @@ void ImGui::DebugNodeFont(ImFont* font)
     Text("Texture Area: about %d px ~%dx%d px", font->MetricsTotalSurface, surface_sqrt, surface_sqrt);
     for (int config_i = 0; config_i < font->ConfigDataCount; config_i++)
         if (font->ConfigData)
-            if (const ImFontConfig* cfg = &font->ConfigData[config_i])
+        {
-                BulletText("Input %d: \'%s\', Oversample: (%d,%d), PixelSnapH: %d, Offset: (%.1f,%.1f)",
+            const ImFontConfig* cfg = &font->ConfigData[config_i];
-                    config_i, cfg->Name, cfg->OversampleH, cfg->OversampleV, cfg->PixelSnapH, cfg->GlyphOffset.x, cfg->GlyphOffset.y);
+            int oversample_h, oversample_v;
+            ImFontAtlasBuildGetOversampleFactors(cfg, &oversample_h, &oversample_v);
+            BulletText("Input %d: \'%s\', Oversample: (%d=>%d,%d=>%d), PixelSnapH: %d, Offset: (%.1f,%.1f)",
+                config_i, cfg->Name, cfg->OversampleH, oversample_h, cfg->OversampleV, oversample_v, cfg->PixelSnapH, cfg->GlyphOffset.x, cfg->GlyphOffset.y);
+        }
 
     // Display all glyphs of the fonts in separate pages of 256 characters
     {

imgui.h

@@ -3254,8 +3254,8 @@ struct ImFontConfig
     bool            MergeMode;              // false    // Merge into previous ImFont, so you can combine multiple inputs font into one ImFont (e.g. ASCII font + icons + Japanese glyphs). You may want to use GlyphOffset.y when merge font of different heights.
     bool            PixelSnapH;             // false    // Align every glyph AdvanceX to pixel boundaries. Useful e.g. if you are merging a non-pixel aligned font with the default font. If enabled, you can set OversampleH/V to 1.
     int             FontNo;                 // 0        // Index of font within TTF/OTF file
-    int             OversampleH;            // 2        // Rasterize at higher quality for sub-pixel positioning. Note the difference between 2 and 3 is minimal. You can reduce this to 1 for large glyphs save memory. Read https://github.com/nothings/stb/blob/master/tests/oversample/README.md for details.
+    int             OversampleH;            // 0 (2)    // Rasterize at higher quality for sub-pixel positioning. 0 == auto == 1 or 2 depending on size. Note the difference between 2 and 3 is minimal. You can reduce this to 1 for large glyphs save memory. Read https://github.com/nothings/stb/blob/master/tests/oversample/README.md for details.
-    int             OversampleV;            // 1        // Rasterize at higher quality for sub-pixel positioning. This is not really useful as we don't use sub-pixel positions on the Y axis.
+    int             OversampleV;            // 0 (1)    // Rasterize at higher quality for sub-pixel positioning. 0 == auto == 1. This is not really useful as we don't use sub-pixel positions on the Y axis.
     float           SizePixels;             //          // Size in pixels for rasterizer (more or less maps to the resulting font height).
     ImVec2          GlyphExtraSpacing;      // 0, 0     // Extra spacing (in pixels) between glyphs when rendered: essentially add to glyph->AdvanceX. Only X axis is supported for now.
     ImVec2          GlyphOffset;            // 0, 0     // Offset all glyphs from this font input.

imgui_draw.cpp

@@ -2374,8 +2374,8 @@ ImFontConfig::ImFontConfig()
 {
     memset(this, 0, sizeof(*this));
     FontDataOwnedByAtlas = true;
-    OversampleH = 2;
+    OversampleH = 0; // Auto == 1 or 2 depending on size
-    OversampleV = 1;
+    OversampleV = 0; // Auto == 1
     GlyphMaxAdvanceX = FLT_MAX;
     RasterizerMultiply = 1.0f;
     RasterizerDensity = 1.0f;
@@ -2573,8 +2573,7 @@ ImFont* ImFontAtlas::AddFont(const ImFontConfig* font_cfg)
     IM_ASSERT(!Locked && "Cannot modify a locked ImFontAtlas between NewFrame() and EndFrame/Render()!");
     IM_ASSERT(font_cfg->FontData != NULL && font_cfg->FontDataSize > 0);
     IM_ASSERT(font_cfg->SizePixels > 0.0f && "Is ImFontConfig struct correctly initialized?");
-    IM_ASSERT(font_cfg->OversampleH > 0 && font_cfg->OversampleV > 0 && "Is ImFontConfig struct correctly initialized?");
+    IM_ASSERT(font_cfg->RasterizerDensity > 0.0f && "Is ImFontConfig struct correctly initialized?");
-    IM_ASSERT(font_cfg->RasterizerDensity > 0.0f);
 
     // Create new font
     if (!font_cfg->MergeMode)
@@ -2858,6 +2857,13 @@ static void UnpackBitVectorToFlatIndexList(const ImBitVector* in, ImVector<int>*
                     out->push_back((int)(((it - it_begin) << 5) + bit_n));
 }
 
+void ImFontAtlasBuildGetOversampleFactors(const ImFontConfig* cfg, int* out_oversample_h, int* out_oversample_v)
+{
+    // Automatically disable horizontal oversampling over size 32
+    *out_oversample_h = (cfg->OversampleH != 0) ? cfg->OversampleH : (cfg->SizePixels * cfg->RasterizerDensity > 32.0f || cfg->PixelSnapH) ? 1 : 2;
+    *out_oversample_v = (cfg->OversampleV != 0) ? cfg->OversampleV : 1;
+}
+
 static bool ImFontAtlasBuildWithStbTruetype(ImFontAtlas* atlas)
 {
     IM_ASSERT(atlas->ConfigData.Size > 0);
@@ -2985,15 +2991,19 @@ static bool ImFontAtlasBuildWithStbTruetype(ImFontAtlas* atlas)
         buf_rects_out_n += src_tmp.GlyphsCount;
         buf_packedchars_out_n += src_tmp.GlyphsCount;
 
-        // Convert our ranges in the format stb_truetype wants
+        // Automatic selection of oversampling parameters
         ImFontConfig& cfg = atlas->ConfigData[src_i];
+        int oversample_h, oversample_v;
+        ImFontAtlasBuildGetOversampleFactors(&cfg, &oversample_h, &oversample_v);
+
+        // Convert our ranges in the format stb_truetype wants
         src_tmp.PackRange.font_size = cfg.SizePixels * cfg.RasterizerDensity;
         src_tmp.PackRange.first_unicode_codepoint_in_range = 0;
         src_tmp.PackRange.array_of_unicode_codepoints = src_tmp.GlyphsList.Data;
         src_tmp.PackRange.num_chars = src_tmp.GlyphsList.Size;
         src_tmp.PackRange.chardata_for_range = src_tmp.PackedChars;
-        src_tmp.PackRange.h_oversample = (unsigned char)cfg.OversampleH;
+        src_tmp.PackRange.h_oversample = (unsigned char)oversample_h;
-        src_tmp.PackRange.v_oversample = (unsigned char)cfg.OversampleV;
+        src_tmp.PackRange.v_oversample = (unsigned char)oversample_v;
 
         // Gather the sizes of all rectangles we will need to pack (this loop is based on stbtt_PackFontRangesGatherRects)
         const float scale = (cfg.SizePixels > 0.0f) ? stbtt_ScaleForPixelHeight(&src_tmp.FontInfo, cfg.SizePixels * cfg.RasterizerDensity) : stbtt_ScaleForMappingEmToPixels(&src_tmp.FontInfo, -cfg.SizePixels * cfg.RasterizerDensity);
@@ -3002,9 +3012,9 @@ static bool ImFontAtlasBuildWithStbTruetype(ImFontAtlas* atlas)
             int x0, y0, x1, y1;
             const int glyph_index_in_font = stbtt_FindGlyphIndex(&src_tmp.FontInfo, src_tmp.GlyphsList[glyph_i]);
             IM_ASSERT(glyph_index_in_font != 0);
-            stbtt_GetGlyphBitmapBoxSubpixel(&src_tmp.FontInfo, glyph_index_in_font, scale * cfg.OversampleH, scale * cfg.OversampleV, 0, 0, &x0, &y0, &x1, &y1);
+            stbtt_GetGlyphBitmapBoxSubpixel(&src_tmp.FontInfo, glyph_index_in_font, scale * oversample_h, scale * oversample_v, 0, 0, &x0, &y0, &x1, &y1);
-            src_tmp.Rects[glyph_i].w = (stbrp_coord)(x1 - x0 + pack_padding + cfg.OversampleH - 1);
+            src_tmp.Rects[glyph_i].w = (stbrp_coord)(x1 - x0 + pack_padding + oversample_h - 1);
-            src_tmp.Rects[glyph_i].h = (stbrp_coord)(y1 - y0 + pack_padding + cfg.OversampleV - 1);
+            src_tmp.Rects[glyph_i].h = (stbrp_coord)(y1 - y0 + pack_padding + oversample_v - 1);
             total_surface += src_tmp.Rects[glyph_i].w * src_tmp.Rects[glyph_i].h;
         }
     }

imgui_internal.h

@@ -3571,6 +3571,7 @@ IMGUI_API void      ImFontAtlasBuildRender8bppRectFromString(ImFontAtlas* atlas,
 IMGUI_API void      ImFontAtlasBuildRender32bppRectFromString(ImFontAtlas* atlas, int x, int y, int w, int h, const char* in_str, char in_marker_char, unsigned int in_marker_pixel_value);
 IMGUI_API void      ImFontAtlasBuildMultiplyCalcLookupTable(unsigned char out_table[256], float in_multiply_factor);
 IMGUI_API void      ImFontAtlasBuildMultiplyRectAlpha8(const unsigned char table[256], unsigned char* pixels, int x, int y, int w, int h, int stride);
+IMGUI_API void      ImFontAtlasBuildGetOversampleFactors(const ImFontConfig* cfg, int* out_oversample_h, int* out_oversample_v);
 
 //-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
 // [SECTION] Test Engine specific hooks (imgui_test_engine)

misc/freetype/imgui_freetype.cpp

@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@
 // - For correct results you need to be using sRGB and convert to linear space in the pixel shader output.
 // - The default dear imgui styles will be impacted by this change (alpha values will need tweaking).
 
-// FIXME: cfg.OversampleH, OversampleV are not supported (but perhaps not so necessary with this rasterizer).
+// FIXME: cfg.OversampleH, OversampleV are not supported, but generally not necessary with this rasterizer because Hinting makes everything look better.
 
 #include "imgui.h"
 #ifndef IMGUI_DISABLE