Improve subtitles support

For each language the extractor builds a list with the available formats sorted (like for video formats), then YoutubeDL selects one of them using the '--sub-format' option which now allows giving the format preferences (for example 'ass/srt/best').
For each format the 'url' field can be set so that we only download the contents if needed, or if the contents needs to be processed (like in crunchyroll) the 'data' field can be used.

The reasons for this change are:
* We weren't checking that the format given with '--sub-format' was available, checking it in each extractor would be repetitive.
* It allows to easily support giving a format preference.
* The subtitles were automatically downloaded in the extractor, but I think that if you use for example the '--dump-json' option you want to finish as fast as possible.

Currently only the ted extractor has been updated, but the old system still works.

test/test_subtitles.py

@@ -27,15 +27,23 @@ class BaseTestSubtitles(unittest.TestCase):
 
     def setUp(self):
         self.DL = FakeYDL()
-        self.ie = self.IE(self.DL)
+        self.ie = self.IE()
+        self.DL.add_info_extractor(self.ie)
 
     def getInfoDict(self):
-        info_dict = self.ie.extract(self.url)
+        info_dict = self.DL.extract_info(self.url, download=False)
         return info_dict
 
     def getSubtitles(self):
         info_dict = self.getInfoDict()
-        return info_dict['subtitles']
+        subtitles = info_dict['subtitles']
+        if not subtitles:
+            return subtitles
+        for sub_info in subtitles.values():
+            if sub_info.get('data') is None:
+                uf = self.DL.urlopen(sub_info['url'])
+                sub_info['data'] = uf.read().decode('utf-8')
+        return dict((l, sub_info['data']) for l, sub_info in subtitles.items())
 
 
 class TestYoutubeSubtitles(BaseTestSubtitles):
@@ -176,7 +184,7 @@ class TestTedSubtitles(BaseTestSubtitles):
 
     def test_no_writesubtitles(self):
         subtitles = self.getSubtitles()
-        self.assertEqual(subtitles, None)
+        self.assertFalse(subtitles)
 
     def test_subtitles(self):
         self.DL.params['writesubtitles'] = True
@@ -196,18 +204,10 @@ def test_allsubtitles(self):
         self.assertTrue(len(subtitles.keys()) >= 28)
 
     def test_list_subtitles(self):
-        self.DL.expect_warning('Automatic Captions not supported by this server')
         self.DL.params['listsubtitles'] = True
         info_dict = self.getInfoDict()
         self.assertEqual(info_dict, None)
 
-    def test_automatic_captions(self):
-        self.DL.expect_warning('Automatic Captions not supported by this server')
-        self.DL.params['writeautomaticsub'] = True
-        self.DL.params['subtitleslang'] = ['en']
-        subtitles = self.getSubtitles()
-        self.assertTrue(len(subtitles.keys()) == 0)
-
     def test_multiple_langs(self):
         self.DL.params['writesubtitles'] = True
         langs = ['es', 'fr', 'de']

youtube_dl/YoutubeDL.py

@@ -154,7 +154,7 @@ class YoutubeDL(object):
     allsubtitles:      Downloads all the subtitles of the video
                        (requires writesubtitles or writeautomaticsub)
     listsubtitles:     Lists all available subtitles for the video
-    subtitlesformat:   Subtitle format [srt/sbv/vtt] (default=srt)
+    subtitlesformat:   The format code for subtitles
     subtitleslangs:    List of languages of the subtitles to download
     keepvideo:         Keep the video file after post-processing
     daterange:         A DateRange object, download only if the upload_date is in the range.
@@ -1019,6 +1019,11 @@ def process_video_result(self, info_dict, download=True):
                 info_dict['timestamp'])
             info_dict['upload_date'] = upload_date.strftime('%Y%m%d')
 
+        if self.params.get('listsubtitles', False):
+            self.list_subtitles(info_dict['id'], info_dict.get('subtitles'))
+            return
+        info_dict['subtitles'] = self.process_subtitles(info_dict['id'], info_dict.get('subtitles'))
+
         # This extractors handle format selection themselves
         if info_dict['extractor'] in ['Youku']:
             if download:
@@ -1147,6 +1152,53 @@ def process_video_result(self, info_dict, download=True):
         info_dict.update(formats_to_download[-1])
         return info_dict
 
+    def process_subtitles(self, video_id, available_subs):
+        """Select the requested subtitles and their format"""
+        if not available_subs:
+            return available_subs
+
+        if self.params.get('allsubtitles', False):
+            requested_langs = available_subs.keys()
+        else:
+            if self.params.get('subtitleslangs', False):
+                requested_langs = self.params.get('subtitleslangs')
+            elif 'en' in available_subs:
+                requested_langs = ['en']
+            else:
+                requested_langs = [list(available_subs.keys())[0]]
+
+        formats_query = self.params.get('subtitlesformat', 'best')
+        formats_preference = formats_query.split('/') if formats_query else []
+        subs = {}
+        for lang in requested_langs:
+            formats = available_subs.get(lang)
+            if formats is None:
+                self.report_warning('%s subtitles not available for %s' % (lang, video_id))
+                continue
+            if isinstance(formats, compat_str):
+                # TODO: convert all IE with subtitles support to the new format
+                # and remove this
+                subs[lang] = {
+                    'ext': formats_preference[0],
+                    'data': formats,
+                }
+                continue
+            for ext in formats_preference:
+                if ext == 'best':
+                    f = formats[-1]
+                    break
+                matches = list(filter(lambda f: f['ext'] == ext, formats))
+                if matches:
+                    f = matches[-1]
+                    break
+            else:
+                f = formats[-1]
+                self.report_warning(
+                    'No subtitle format found matching "%s" for language %s, '
+                    'using %s' % (formats_query, lang, f['ext']))
+            subs[lang] = f
+        return subs
+
     def process_info(self, info_dict):
         """Process a single resolved IE result."""
 
@@ -1253,11 +1305,18 @@ def process_info(self, info_dict):
             # subtitles download errors are already managed as troubles in relevant IE
             # that way it will silently go on when used with unsupporting IE
             subtitles = info_dict['subtitles']
-            sub_format = self.params.get('subtitlesformat', 'srt')
+            for sub_lang, sub_info in subtitles.items():
-            for sub_lang in subtitles.keys():
+                sub_format = sub_info['ext']
-                sub = subtitles[sub_lang]
+                if sub_info.get('data') is not None:
-                if sub is None:
+                    sub_data = sub_info['data']
-                    continue
+                else:
+                    try:
+                        uf = self.urlopen(sub_info['url'])
+                        sub_data = uf.read().decode('utf-8')
+                    except (compat_urllib_error.URLError, compat_http_client.HTTPException, socket.error) as err:
+                        self.report_warning('Unable to download subtitle for "%s": %s' %
+                                            (sub_lang, compat_str(err)))
+                        continue
                 try:
                     sub_filename = subtitles_filename(filename, sub_lang, sub_format)
                     if self.params.get('nooverwrites', False) and os.path.exists(encodeFilename(sub_filename)):
@@ -1265,7 +1324,7 @@ def process_info(self, info_dict):
                     else:
                         self.to_screen('[info] Writing video subtitles to: ' + sub_filename)
                         with io.open(encodeFilename(sub_filename), 'w', encoding='utf-8') as subfile:
-                            subfile.write(sub)
+                            subfile.write(sub_data)
                 except (OSError, IOError):
                     self.report_error('Cannot write subtitles file ' + sub_filename)
                     return
@@ -1586,6 +1645,18 @@ def list_thumbnails(self, info_dict):
             ['ID', 'width', 'height', 'URL'],
             [[t['id'], t.get('width', 'unknown'), t.get('height', 'unknown'), t['url']] for t in thumbnails]))
 
+    def list_subtitles(self, video_id, subtitles):
+        if not subtitles:
+            self.to_screen('%s has no subtitles' % video_id)
+            return
+        header_line = 'Language    formats'
+        sub_lines = [
+            '%-12s%s' % (lang, ', '.join(f['ext'] for f in reversed(formats)))
+            for lang, formats in subtitles.items()]
+        self.to_screen(
+            'Available subtitles for %s:\n%s\n%s' %
+            (video_id, header_line, '\n'.join(sub_lines)))
+
     def urlopen(self, req):
         """ Start an HTTP download """
 

youtube_dl/__init__.py

@@ -226,7 +226,6 @@ def _real_main(argv=None):
     if opts.embedsubtitles:
         postprocessors.append({
             'key': 'FFmpegEmbedSubtitle',
-            'subtitlesformat': opts.subtitlesformat,
         })
     if opts.xattrs:
         postprocessors.append({'key': 'XAttrMetadata'})

youtube_dl/extractor/common.py

@@ -151,8 +151,14 @@ class InfoExtractor(object):
                     If not explicitly set, calculated from timestamp.
     uploader_id:    Nickname or id of the video uploader.
     location:       Physical location where the video was filmed.
-    subtitles:      The subtitle file contents as a dictionary in the format
+    subtitles:      The available subtitles as a dictionary in the format
-                    {language: subtitles}.
+                    {language: subformats}. "subformats" is a list sorted from
+                    lower to higher preference, each element is a dictionary
+                    with the "ext" entry and one of:
+                        * "data": The subtitles file contents
+                        * "url": A url pointing to the subtitles file
+                    Note: YoutubeDL.extract_info will get the requested
+                    format and replace the "subformats" list with it.
     duration:       Length of the video in seconds, as an integer.
     view_count:     How many users have watched the video on the platform.
     like_count:     Number of positive ratings of the video
@@ -993,6 +999,16 @@ def is_suitable(self, age_limit):
             any_restricted = any_restricted or is_restricted
         return not any_restricted
 
+    def extract_subtitles(self, *args, **kwargs):
+        subtitles = {}
+        list_subtitles = self._downloader.params.get('listsubtitles')
+        if self._downloader.params.get('writesubtitles', False) or list_subtitles:
+            subtitles.update(self._get_subtitles(*args, **kwargs))
+        return subtitles
+
+    def _get_subtitles(self, *args, **kwargs):
+        raise NotImplementedError("This method must be implemented by subclasses")
+
 
 class SearchInfoExtractor(InfoExtractor):
     """

youtube_dl/extractor/ted.py

@@ -3,14 +3,14 @@
 import json
 import re
 
-from .subtitles import SubtitlesInfoExtractor
+from .common import InfoExtractor
 
 from ..compat import (
     compat_str,
 )
 
 
-class TEDIE(SubtitlesInfoExtractor):
+class TEDIE(InfoExtractor):
     _VALID_URL = r'''(?x)
         (?P<proto>https?://)
         (?P<type>www|embed(?:-ssl)?)(?P<urlmain>\.ted\.com/
@@ -165,9 +165,6 @@ def _talk_info(self, url, video_name):
         video_id = compat_str(talk_info['id'])
         # subtitles
         video_subtitles = self.extract_subtitles(video_id, talk_info)
-        if self._downloader.params.get('listsubtitles', False):
-            self._list_available_subtitles(video_id, talk_info)
-            return
 
         thumbnail = talk_info['thumb']
         if not thumbnail.startswith('http'):
@@ -183,13 +180,18 @@ def _talk_info(self, url, video_name):
             'duration': talk_info.get('duration'),
         }
 
-    def _get_available_subtitles(self, video_id, talk_info):
+    def _get_subtitles(self, video_id, talk_info):
         languages = [lang['languageCode'] for lang in talk_info.get('languages', [])]
         if languages:
             sub_lang_list = {}
             for l in languages:
-                url = 'http://www.ted.com/talks/subtitles/id/%s/lang/%s/format/srt' % (video_id, l)
+                sub_lang_list[l] = [
-                sub_lang_list[l] = url
+                    {
+                        'url': 'http://www.ted.com/talks/subtitles/id/%s/lang/%s/format/%s' % (video_id, l, ext),
+                        'ext': ext,
+                    }
+                    for ext in ['ted', 'srt']
+                ]
             return sub_lang_list
         else:
             self._downloader.report_warning('video doesn\'t have subtitles')

youtube_dl/options.py

@@ -387,8 +387,8 @@ def _hide_login_info(opts):
         help='lists all available subtitles for the video')
     subtitles.add_option(
         '--sub-format',
-        action='store', dest='subtitlesformat', metavar='FORMAT', default='srt',
+        action='store', dest='subtitlesformat', metavar='FORMAT', default='best',
-        help='subtitle format (default=srt) ([sbv/vtt] youtube only)')
+        help='subtitle format, accepts formats preference, for example: "ass/srt/best"')
     subtitles.add_option(
         '--sub-lang', '--sub-langs', '--srt-lang',
         action='callback', dest='subtitleslangs', metavar='LANGS', type='str',

youtube_dl/postprocessor/ffmpeg.py

@@ -453,10 +453,6 @@ class FFmpegEmbedSubtitlePP(FFmpegPostProcessor):
         'zu': 'zul',
     }
 
-    def __init__(self, downloader=None, subtitlesformat='srt'):
-        super(FFmpegEmbedSubtitlePP, self).__init__(downloader)
-        self._subformat = subtitlesformat
-
     @classmethod
     def _conver_lang_code(cls, code):
         """Convert language code from ISO 639-1 to ISO 639-2/T"""
@@ -472,7 +468,7 @@ def run(self, information):
 
         sub_langs = [key for key in information['subtitles']]
         filename = information['filepath']
-        input_files = [filename] + [subtitles_filename(filename, lang, self._subformat) for lang in sub_langs]
+        input_files = [filename] + [subtitles_filename(filename, lang, sub_info['ext']) for lang, sub_info in information['subtitles'].items()]
 
         opts = [
             '-map', '0',